Need to know
- You don’t have to spend top dollar to get a good knife, but the cheapest knives are unlikely to stay sharp
- We found that sales and discounts on kitchen knives are a regular occurrence so you will rarely need to pay the full recommended retail price
- Caring for your knife properly will ensure it lasts as long as possible
If you do a lot of cooking from scratch, a good knife is an essential piece of kitchen kit. It's one of the first things you'll reach for each time you begin to prepare a meal and something you'll use time and time again. Whether you're a master chef or a disaster chef, having a sharp kitchen knife will help make cooking easier, safer and simply a more pleasant experience.
But for a tool that humans have used for literal millennia, the price variation on different knives – anywhere from less than $100 to over $400 – can be more than a little perplexing.
Choosing the right knife
What makes the best knife can be subjective. Is the weight of a knife important to you? Are you concerned about Rockwell hardness? Is the type of steel it's made from key? All of these factors can influence your decision, as can the simple issue of price.
Sami Levett is a chef and recipe developer for QuiteLike, a subscription meal box service. She says that a well-made, sharp and comfortable knife will make your time in the kitchen safer, more enjoyable and more efficient. It will also help you make the most of your ingredients.
"A good knife can cut effectively and precisely through ingredients, preserving the ingredient quality," she says.
A dull, poor-quality knife can not only damage ingredients – for example, delicate herbs can be crushed and bruised when preparing without a sharp knife – but it's also a safety risk.
A dull, poor quality knife can be a safety risk.
"A dull blade requires the knife wielder to press down with force," says Sami.
"The unnecessary pressure can cause kitchen accidents like the knife slipping." If you'd rather avoid cutting the tip of your finger instead of the tip of a zucchini, a sharp, well-honed blade is crucial.
Our CHOICE experts recently compared 15 chef's knives from a range of brands and price points to find out which blade is best. Our test included knives that cost as little as $8, and as much as $400 and for each one we assessed cutting performance, sharpness and ease of use.
We found that, as is often the case, price is not necessarily an indicator of performance, though in this case it does play a part.
Do you need to spend hundreds on a chef's knife?
According to CHOICE expert, Peter Zaluzny, probably not. But a cut-price knife might not impress either.
"Knives that cost more than $100 outperformed almost all of the cheaper models in our test," says Peter. "But you don't necessarily need to pay top dollar – around $400 – to get a very good knife that retains its sharpness."
Our tests found plenty of mid-priced knives that are good-quality options for home cooks.
Should you buy an $8 Anko knife from Kmart or Target?
While our tests didn't find any knives for less than $100 that we would recommend, that doesn't mean they don't have their place.
"Cheaper knives may not perform as well as those that cost over $100," says Peter. "But their performance-to-cost ratio is often much better. In other words, some cheaper knives aren't as good but offer much better value for money. There are still good options if you're on a budget."
CHOICE test coordinator Elias Plastiras, who conducted our recent test, agrees. As part of our in-house testing he sliced his way through 30 tomatoes, 30 onions and 45 carrots, assessing each knife for how easily it cut through each food. The less effort needed to cut, the higher the score.
After our in-house assessment, we then worked with the University of New South Wales to conduct an assessment that simulated wear and dulling of the knives. This revealed that the cheaper knives in our test did not retain their edges as well as the more expensive options.
"You don't have to spend a lot to get a nice, sharp knife, but you might need to spend at least $100 to get one that will stay sharp for a longer period," says Elias.
Should I pay full price for an expensive knife?
There are certain categories of products where we see frequent sales and discounts. For example, in our mattress review, we find that when shopping both online and in-store you can often make substantial savings on recommended retail prices thanks to sales that offer big price reductions. After shopping around for this test we found that it seems to be a similar story with knives.
Want a big-name brand? Check the sales
"All but the cheapest knives are pretty well permanently on sale," says Peter.
"Many homeware retailers slice a reasonable chunk off the RRP across most of the year and prices often drop even further during popular sales periods like the end of financial year, Black Friday or Boxing Day."
Peter recommends that if you find a knife you want, it pays to shop around online and compare prices. "You won't have to work very hard to find a deal," he says.
Regularly sharpening your knife will help it last longer.
How long should your knife last?
A good knife will last a long time, provided it's cared for and stored correctly.
Sami suggests that you follow these steps to keep your knife sharp for as long as possible.
1. Sharpen regularly
Routine sharpening with the correct materials such as a whetstone or fine ceramic honing steel will keep your knife working as it should. There are professional services available that can do this for you, at places such as Mister Minit stores across Australia, if you aren't able to do it yourself at home.
2. Wash it well
Never put your blades in the dishwasher and make sure you dry them using paper towel rather than a tea towel. "Tea towels can leave residue on the knife, resulting in rust, depending on the metal it's made from," says Sami.
3. Cut wisely
Don't use your knife to cut directly on hard surfaces such as bench tops, sinks or chopping boards made from glass or bamboo. "Ideally your chopping board should either be wood end-grain or soft plastic," says Sami.
4. Store it properly
Keeping your knife in the box or scabbard it came in, or in a knife block will help protect the blade. Storing a kitchen knife loose in a cutlery drawer is not only a safety hazard, but it's also likely to cause your blade to dull more quickly.
For help on choosing the right knife as well as tips on costs, discounts, and paying the recommended price our buying guide has lots of advice.
We're on your side
In more than 60 years of making a difference for Australian consumers, we've never taken ads or sponsorship.
Instead we're funded by members who value expert reviews and independent product testing.
With no self-interest behind our advice, you don't just buy smarter, you get the answers that you need.
You know without hesitation what's safe for you and your family.
And you'll never be alone when something goes wrong or a business treats you unfairly.
Learn more about CHOICE membership today
Stock images: Getty, unless otherwise stated.
